Logo
Overview

Practice: Case Studies & Activity Analysis

January 22, 2025
2 min read

Case Study 1: The Sailors & Scurvy

Scenario: In 1746, Scottish physician James Lind observed sailors suffering from bleeding gums and swollen limbs during long sea voyages.

Analysis:

  • Problem: Sailors ate preserved food (dry biscuits, salted meat) for months with no fresh produce.
  • Observation: Those who ate lemons and oranges recovered.
  • Scientific Conclusion: The sailors lacked Vitamin C, which is found in citrus fruits. The deficiency disease is called Scurvy. Vitamin C is crucial for healthy gums and wound healing.

Case Study 2: Goitre in the Himalayas

Scenario: In the 1960s, people in the Northern plains and Himalayas had swollen necks.

Analysis:

  • Problem: The soil in these regions was deficient in Iodine, so the crops and water also lacked Iodine.
  • Symptom: Swelling of the thyroid gland in the neck.
  • Solution: The Government introduced Iodised Salt (Salt mixed with Potassium Iodate).
  • Scientific Conclusion: Iodine is essential for the production of thyroxine hormone. Its deficiency causes Goitre.

Activity 3.9 Analysis: Label Reading

Let’s compare the Nutrition Labels provided in the text mathematically.

Nutrient (per 100g)Potato WafersRoasted ChanaWinner
Energy536 kcal355 kcalChana (Lower calorie density is better for snacking)
Fats35.0 g6.26 gChana (Much lower fat)
Proteins7.0 g18.64 gChana (High protein)
Fibre4.8 g16.8 gChana (High fibre aids digestion)

Conclusion: Potato wafers are calorie-dense with high fat, classifying them as Junk Food. Roasted Chana is nutrient-dense with high protein and fibre, making it a Healthy Snack.

35g (Wafers)6g (Chana)Fat Content Comparison